Sunday, January 6, 2013

Council Minutes 12/3/12

Issue
Discussion
Resolution
Opening Prayer
Doug asked us to think about the season of advent as a time of waiting. How does waiting resonate with each of us?


Liaisons Report
-Norma, Art, Rick
Rick shared information from the Worship Ministry meeting, which centered mainly about media and live streaming. There was also concern expressed about the reduced size of teams in our new governance structure. Discussed how the Beach Street doors can be more of a welcoming entrance to the community.
Norma shared highlights from the last Assets Ministry meeting. The group felt that the minutes on the website should only stay for one year so that it doesn’t get overwhelming. There needs to be a decision made about where they will go. The Endowment Policy Task Force needs to get back together and present new version of document that has been in the works.
Art had no report from Discipleship/Fellowship.
Motion to accept liaison reports as presented.

Liaisons will remind ministries to get reports to Sarah by the end of December.

Norma will let Nathan Poore know what would need to be done to be ready for Annual Affirmation. It sounds like it would be too much to do for this year.

M/S/A

Bylaws Recommendation
- Allison DiMatteo
Allison explained the process used by the Bylaws Task Force and shared some of the themes that arose. The Task Force agreed that the new governance structure and bylaws should continue. Other recommendations were made to change the bylaws based on information gathered. The Task Force also suggested topics for the council and others to consider for improvement of the workings of the church.

Dolly thanked Allison and the Task Force for all of their hard work.

We discussed why a treasurer might have a term limit of 3 years. The safety of the church encourages having term limits for this position. Doug expressed a worry about loss of financial institutional memory. It would only work if the Assistant Treasurer actively learned the role and could take over as Treasurer at the end of the three years. Suggestion to Bylaws: make the Treasurer a 3-year term with the ability to renew annually, with a 6-year total as the term limit.

Motion to accept the Bylaws Task Force recommendation as amended.










Allison and Task Force will propose the exact wording for Annual Affirmation.

Allison will take our suggestion regarding the amendment for treasurer.

M/S/A
Stewardship
- Linda Lambert
The corrected total to date is $256,784 with 169 pledgers (less than what was announced). There are 36 pledgers from last year that we haven’t heard from yet. The stewardship team members will call all 36 of these people by Wednesday to encourage them to provide their 2013 pledge information. There is positive news – the increase in most pledges is significant. We expect the total to support many of the requests.

The Budget Task Force has met once and $378K is the first draft of the 2013 expenses.

Doug noted that the council appreciates what Linda and the stewardship team have done to encourage members and friends to support the life and mission of First Parish.

Budget Task Force
- Dolly
Dolly asked the council for any suggestions for the Budget Task Force. This group will meet for the second time tomorrow night.

For example, does the council want the BTF to move forward with Stephen Ministries? It appears that we have the money to begin this program, but do we have the people and time? Currently Doug is the only ordained person on staff and he has little or no free time available for this new endeavor. We do have many ordained people in our congregation, which may be a solution. Perhaps the Minister of Visitation could be reinvigorated to include the responsibility of Stephen Ministries.

Doug shared that he is concerned that recently we have financially given more to ourselves and less to others.

Rick reminded us that the Budget Task Force would also need to consider staff raises and possibly replacing cuts made last year.
The Budget Task Force should be told about our SM discussion. Council agreed that we would like to try to make SM work in 2013 if possible. BTF would need to consider extra salary for a part time staff person to support this. In addition staff raises, administration needs, etc. should remain on the “bucket list” for BTF to prioritize as money becomes available via pledges and income possibilities.

You Tube Church Services, Lawyers Fees
-Freddue
Freddie noted that we are technically illegally streaming by playing copyrighted music online. Doug suggested to Media that a lawyer look at this to be sure.

We would hate to stop live streaming for fear of legal ramifications. We should do our research and find out what we can do to protect this ministry. Doug would like the council to commit enough money to allow us to get the correct legal information.

Doug will try to find out information about other churches who may live stream.
Dolly will add this to the January agenda and Doug, Freddie and Mac will provide information they have found.

Council Members at Large
-Dolly
Dolly asked for suggestions related to inviting new Council Members At Large and received some suggestions. Rick thinks that it would be good to look at old Annual Reports: Who were our former leaders who have shown that they know the commitment involved? Attendance at meetings is critical. Doug countered that new eyes also have great value. Anyone on the council needs to be open to change and to listening to others. Council members should believe in the mission of this church.




Dolly will bring the criteria and the suggested names to Dale and Allison.
Guiding Principles Statement
-Dolly
Dolly asked us to look at the rough draft underway and consider ways to improve this document.
All council members should read and share suggestions with Dolly before the January meeting.

Treasurer & Secretary Reports
-Peggy, Marsha
Peggy asked for questions about the treasurer’s report. Doug asked and we clarified that the Period Activity was mistakenly printed as Jan-Nov instead of just November.

Marsha thanks Norma for stepping in as clerk and taking minutes for the last two council meetings.

M/S/A to accept the treasurer’s report.

Marsha must forward Norma’s minutes to all council members!

Potluck
-Dolly

As council we will hold another potluck on January 12th. Dolly spoke to Gary Dixon about playing the piano for entertainment. We will need to advertise, determine the format, make a dessert.
Dolly asked for a couple of people to get together to do the detail work. The focus could be hospitality and how we all have a role in making First Parish more welcoming.





Dolly and Mac will meet to plan this.
Next Meeting
Monday, January 7, 2012 at 6:30pm.

Note: Other upcoming dates to save:
January 12 - Potluck
January 20 - Annual Affirmation
At least 30 days after his January 6 Ecclesiastical Council - Commissioning for Peter Stickney (This is a big deal! There are three stages: annual licensing, lifetime commissioning, and ordination.)

Marianne is willing to do Skype again. Not ideal, but better than not being with us at all.
Adjourn
Adjourned at 9:05pm.
Doug closed us in prayer.


Present: Dolly (Moderator), Mac (Vice Moderator), Peggy (Treasurer), Marsha (Clerk), Marianne (via Skype), Art, Jamie, Rick, and Norma (Members at Large), Doug (Senior Minister)
Guests: Freddie Connelly, Allison DiMatteo, Linda Lambert, Judy Klingensmith

Council Minutes 11/5/12


Issue
Discussion
Resolution
Opening Devotional
Individual sharing of examples of Temporary Art
Led by Doug & Dolly

Rental Process
David Foster attended the CC meeting as the person on the Facilities Team who processes applications for rental of church space.  His concern centering around the use of space by Mainers United in support of gay marriage was twofold: 
1)    The established process was not followed resulting in the Facilities Team not even knowing that proponents of gay marriage were using the conference room as a call center. Doug took personal responsibility for not following the procedure.
2)    David also questioned whether this use of our church is prohibited by our bylaws and by the IRS – the latter which could endanger our tax-exempt status. 
David presented his research findings that the church staff had approved the use of the church space but  had inadvertently not followed the appropriate procedure to go through Facilities.   
Regarding concern # 2,  David studied the rental agreement, the church bylaws and the IRS laws regarding rental space by non-profit groups.  He found that the rental agreement only prohibits use of church space by candidates so this situation was not in violation.  The church bylaws state that “the Facilities Team will assure that the purpose of such organizations serve the public good and conform to the stated purpose and goals of the church.”  David once again found that according to current bylaws this rental could be approved.    The IRS language was in agreement with the two previous sources. 

David found that the rental was in compliance with all three but suggested that the language of the rental agreement and/or the bylaws should  be reviewed and perhaps modified to provide additional guidance to Facilities should rental to social interest groups become an issue in the future.
David was commended for the clear,  thorough, yet concise presentation of his concerns regarding this rental situation.



This issue of rentals to political groups will be forwarded to the current bylaw task force.  The task force will be asked to refer to the IRS website as they review and perhaps modify language in the bylaws.

Updating of the rental agreement should be explored by the Facilities  Team who should also consider IRS language.

Dolly will  inform David Foster of these two former points prior to this week’s  meeting of Facilities.

Dolly  will write a letter to John Brockington, head of Facilities commending David on his integrity in handling this difficult situation.


The role of the church in speaking on social issues in a public forum


The Maine Coalition asked Maine churches to partner with them in support of the issue of gay marriage.  Many churches did, but the CC of FPC chose to discuss the matter as a group before making a decision.  Given several dates for a special meeting, CC members just could not assemble until tonight’s regularly scheduled meeting.  The timing was too late for a statement of support, but the topic seemed important for discussion. 
Due to the wide variety of opinions within the church, can the CC speak for the membership on social justice issues in a public forum?  On the other hand, do we as a Christian association have a responsibility to speak out on social issues?
The question was whether the CC could speak for the congregation or whether – at the opposite extreme - a special all church meeting would need to be called for a vote.
Since the congregation voted that FPC be an open and affirming church, much discussion centered around whether the body of members had already given their support.  Was supporting gay marriage, the affirming part of open and affirming?
After much discussion it was determined that guiding principles needed to be developed for issues of this type.



Doug, Dolly, and Art will meet to develop Guiding Principles that will help us be more comfortable taking a stand on  social justice issues in a public forum.


We will also have discussion  of Guiding Principles  with the congregation through such avenues as Focus Groups and Pot Luck Suppers.


Comments at  Pulse Taking Pot Luck Supper











Bringing together bullet points from the Pulse Taking Pot Luck
The numbers are the number of tables that came back with the same or very similar bullet points

OUR CHURCH HAS LOTS OF NEEDS (6)
visitation (2), community connection improvement(3), new energy of new members, burnout of many members, Too few people doing the larger share of running the church, more adult education offerings, better ministry to youth and young adults, adult SS, draw from base of new members to serve on Teams, esp parents of teens

AN ASSOCIATE MINISTER COULD HELP OUR NEEDS (3)

OUR CHURCH HAS A LOT TO OFFER (2)
FPC is a well kept secret – quality worship, mission, pertinent book discussions, children’s Sunday school, excellent music program, pastors discretionary fund as well as help to those that walk in off the street, prayer shawl ministry, active prayer life, food pantry awareness and witness. 

FAITH ISSUES
Our membership does respond when asked
Position of Associate minister calls for more congregational support, both financial and volunteers (2)
We should not view new members as dollar signs
We need to live in the direction of Faith and dreams (2)

COMMUNICATION
FPC is a well kept secret – we need to get the word out
We have a problem with coordination and communication
Continued conversation about Stephen Ministries, to be informed
CC needs to be clearer about the sum of increased pledge amounts needed to fund an associate minister



























An eUpdate will be sent out including a summary of this information as well.

Associate Minister Conversation and Pledging Increase of CC Members

The CC continues to support hiring an Associate minister.  A 22% increase in pledging is necessary to make this goal a reality.  CC members were asked to confidentially indicate their level of pledge increase so that we could determine if this group supported the issue financially.  Attending members averaged a 29.5% increase.  Three non-attending members will be polled as well.

We discussed the impact of a 22% increase on some families. 
Another option that was suggested was making a 10% increase now for 2013 with the commitment of making an additional 10% increase for the 2014 budget.   This plan would allow us to pursue the hiring of an Associate Minister over a two year pledge cycle. 
Dolly will e-mail the 3 absent members and ask them to e-mail the treasurer regarding their intended pledge increase.

Dolly, Norma, and Doug will compose an eUpdate  containing the results of the Pulse Taking Pot Luck and encouraging pledgers to increase their pledges over either a one or two year period to make hiring an Associate minister financially feasible.

Budget Task Force
Voting on people considered for the Budget Task Force.
Lisa Tarbox, John Brockington, Marsha Synder, Dennis Burnham, Peggy Warden, Mac Coldwell, Dolly Anagnostis

Unanimous approval

Reports from Liaisons
Discipleship/Fellowship Ministry – Art Morrisette
Meetings are not being held.  Art is considering stepping down as liaison.
Program development is part of this Ministry.  They developed a wonderful program not as part of a Ministry but on their own.  The head of this group – Tom Kircher – is a great example of a person who took an idea and moved on it.  The Face of Hunger workshop was organized by a group of committed individuals for a worthy cause.  Hats off to them.

Worship Ministry – Rick Campbell
The Media Team is considering using YouTube for streaming and video storage as a cost saving move.  They will, however, need money for maintenance of equipment.
The Ministry discussed reasons for volunteering and how it benefits us as individuals.  The Media team may do a video illustrating this.
Floor and Altar has created artwork to be displayed in the Sanctuary.

Asset Ministry – Norma Gorham
The website group reports 4,ooo hits a month.
Facilities shared that we now have written approval to permanently remove the center handrail on the steps of the parking lot entrance.
Exterior painting has been completed.
The team is looking at a long range contract with Spurwink which will benefit both parties. 
Investments reported a loss 2nd quarter but gains 3rd
On the agenda for next month will be a discussion of how long meeting minutes should be kept on the website.  Further we will discuss archiving all minutes.
The Endowment Policy Task Force has been at a standstill but will be moving forward.

Art & Dolly will meet to discuss the liaison situation for this ministry
Date for Annual Affirmation
Dolly proposed the date of Jan 20th for the Annual Affirmation meeting with a snow date of Jan 27th.  A 20% attendance is required to meet a quorum – approximately 100 people.

Unanimous vote of acceptance.
Next Pot Luck
The next pot luck supper will be held on Jan 12th with the topic of discussion being The Hospitality Team.

Dolly will contact Gary Dixon to play the piano.
Minutes of Last Meeting
Approved and accepted
Unanimous



Treasurer’s Report

Approved and accepted
Unanimous vote

Doug will get an explanation of what appeared to be overspending by CE.
Closing Prayer

Led by Doug.

Attended








Not in Attendance



Dolly Anagnostis - Moderator
Doug Nielsen - Pastor
Peggy Warden -  Teasurer
Norma Gorham – Member at large – took notes
Jamie Beals  - Member at large
Judi Klingensmith - Member at large
Art Morrissette - Member at large
Rick Campbell - Member at large

Marsha Synder
Marianne Cook
Mac Coldwell